Standards

Should You Get Rewards for Good Grades?

Illustration by Tom Garrett; Africa Studio/Adobe Stock (hand); Shutterstock.com (all other images); Courtesy of families (Prisha and Brogan)

In Waco, Texas, good grades can earn kids praise—and prizes. Last fall, a collectibles shop started a new program. Students receive one dollar in store credit for every A they earn. 

Third-grader Frank Workman was the first to cash in. He got straight A’s on his report card and earned $6. He used it to help pay for an expensive Pokémon card. 

“It makes me want to work harder,” Frank says. “I’m excited to get my report card.”

Many people say programs like this one are a smart way to help kids succeed. They point out that prizes give students a goal to work toward. 

But not everyone wants to give rewards for grades. Some teachers and parents say it can send the message that grades are all that matter to a student’s success. They argue that rewards for good grades aren’t fair to kids who try their best but still don’t get A’s.

Here’s what two of our readers think.

Who wouldn’t look forward to getting a prize when they’re under stress from their schoolwork? Getting rewards motivates students to finish their work in class, do their homework, and keep trying their best.

Plus, knowing they will earn a reward like a new book or favorite snack can help students with goal setting. It pushes us to work toward something and achieve it. That can prepare us for the future and help us become responsible adults.

Giving rewards for good grades teaches kids that a letter on a piece of paper is more valuable than effort. It can also hurt some kids’ feelings, especially when they’re working hard and showing improvement. It would be better if the whole class earned a privilege, like extra recess time, when the teacher sees that everyone is putting in a lot of effort. 

Also, receiving a prize every time you get a good grade can make gifts feel less special. Besides, learning something new is its own reward!

What does your class think?

Should you get rewards for good grades?

Please enter a valid number of votes for one class to proceed.

Should you get rewards for good grades?

Please select an answer to vote.

Should you get rewards for good grades?

0%
0votes
{{result.answer}}
Total Votes: 0
Thank you for voting!
Sorry, an error occurred and your vote could not be processed. Please try again later.
Skills Sheets (1)
Text-to-Speech