Illustration of kids having a lemonade stand sale saying they only accept debit cards and not cash

Illustration by R.J. Matson; debate photos courtesy of families

Should Kids Have Debit Cards?

You don’t need to carry bills and coins to have money in your pocket. Some kids keep their money on debit cards. These plastic cards are linked to a bank account. They allow people to access their money and buy things, using a password called a personal identification number, or PIN.

“When you use a debit card for payment, it is like you are telling your bank to send a certain amount of your money to the store electronically,” explains Walter Andal, the author of the book Finance 101 for Kids

Many parents like the convenience of debit cards. They can instantly send money to their kids’ accounts—even if they don’t have cash in their wallet. Parents also see debit cards as a good tool for teaching kids about managing money. Debit card apps let kids easily track how much they spend and save. Also, a lost debit card can’t be used unless the password is known, but lost cash is often gone forever.

However, other people argue that paying with a card instead of actual money can lead kids to make poor decisions. 

“You might be tempted to buy things that you do not really need,” Andal warns.

Here’s what two of our readers think.

My parents give me a weekly allowance on my debit card for completing my chores. It’s easier than having to carry cash. All my money is on the card. 

I use a debit card app to keep track of my money. I divide it into three categories: spending, saving, and giving. I’m able to set a limit for how much money I’ll spend, and I can watch my savings grow every week. Having a debit card is teaching me how to be responsible for my money, which will prepare me for the future.

I sometimes earn money by having bake sales or helping out with chores at home. And I like to get paid in cash! 

Some people say debit card apps are the best way for kids to manage money, but I disagree. With a debit card, you can just swipe and not think about how much you’re actually spending. It’s easier to stick to a budget when you have only a $5 or $10 bill in your pocket.

Plus, counting out money and the change when you buy something can improve your math skills.

What does your class think?

Should kids have debit cards?

Please enter a valid number of votes for one class to proceed.

Should kids have debit cards?

Please select an answer to vote.

Should kids have debit cards?

0%
0votes
{{result.answer}}
Total Votes: 0
Thank you for voting!
Sorry, an error occurred and your vote could not be processed. Please try again later.
Skills Sheets (1)
Text-to-Speech